top of page

Widerspruch or Lawsuit? Challenging an Immigration Decision in Germany

3 days ago
4 min read

German administrative law starts from a simple rule: before you sue over a decision, the authority gets a second look. That second look is the Widerspruch, a formal objection (§ 68 VwGO). In immigration matters the rule has many exceptions, and the refusal notice tells you which one applies to you. Whether you object first or go straight to court decides where your next letter goes and who answers it.

The rule and its exceptions

Under § 68 Abs. 1 VwGO, a lawsuit against an administrative decision, and against the refusal of something you applied for, normally requires an objection procedure first. The law makes exceptions where a statute dispenses with it and where the decision comes from a supreme federal or state authority. The federal states (Länder) have used the first exception widely, so whether an objection is needed for a residence permit can depend on the state you live in and on the type of decision.

The reliable guide is the Rechtsbehelfsbelehrung (instructions on legal remedies) at the end of the notice. It names the remedy, the place to file it and the deadline. If it says Widerspruch, you object to the authority. If it says Klage, you sue at the administrative court.

Visa refusals go straight to court

Visas are refused by German embassies and consulates on behalf of the Federal Foreign Office, a supreme federal authority. There is therefore no objection procedure. The remedy is an action at the Verwaltungsgericht Berlin within one month, or a new application. The voluntary remonstration that used to come first was abolished on 1 July 2025.

Naturalization and residence decisions in Berlin

In Berlin, a refusal of naturalization by the Landesamt für Einwanderung (LEA) is followed by a Widerspruch, which the Senate Department for the Interior and Sport decides; the objection itself is filed with the LEA. For residence decisions of the LEA, check the instructions in your notice; they name the remedy that applies to that decision. In other states, the same type of decision can lead to a different remedy, which is another reason to read the notice rather than rely on what worked for a friend in another city.

Deadline and form

An objection must be filed within one month of notification of the decision (§ 70 Abs. 1 VwGO). It can be filed in writing, in a recognized electronic form, or in person for the record at the authority. A plain email is generally not enough. It is also on time if it reaches the authority that decides on the objection. If the instructions on remedies were missing or wrong, the period is generally one year instead (§ 70 Abs. 2 with § 58 VwGO). The reasons can follow later, and the authority can look at the whole case again, including whether its decision was sensible as well as lawful.

An objection does not always protect your stay

An objection usually suspends the decision (§ 80 Abs. 1 VwGO). Immigration law removes that effect for several decisions, including the refusal of a residence permit (§ 84 Abs. 1 AufenthG). Filing an objection against a refused extension therefore does not keep your right to stay on its own. An urgent application to the court may be needed at the same time.

Three months without an answer

The authority deciding on the objection should decide within a reasonable time. If three months pass without a decision and there is no sufficient reason for the delay, an action for failure to act (Untätigkeitsklage, § 75 VwGO) becomes possible. The same rule applies to the original application, so a case can reach court even if no one ever rules on the objection.

When to get a lawyer

The objection is the first chance to put the full picture before the authority, and it is often the cheapest stage at which to win. Advice helps with three questions: whether the notice names the right remedy, whether the objection must be paired with an urgent application to protect your stay, and what evidence answers the reasons given. If the deadline is close, the objection can be filed first and the reasons supplied afterwards.

Make the most of a review

Fiona Macdonald is a German immigration lawyer (Rechtsanwältin) who advises on refusals of residence permits, permanent residence and naturalization. In a Rejection & Hearing Review she reads the decision and your documents before the call and tells you which remedy applies, what it should say and what it costs. Fiona Macdonald advises clients anywhere in Germany and internationally by video.

Related reading

Sources

Last reviewed: November 2026 — RAin Fiona Macdonald

This article reflects information available at the review date above and may not remain current as rules and practice change. It is general information only, not legal advice, and does not create a lawyer–client relationship. Liability for reliance on its contents is excluded to the extent permitted by law.

© 2026 Fiona Macdonald Rechtsanwältin

​

Imprint

bottom of page