top of page

Your Naturalization Was Refused: What to Do Next

Nov 6
7 min read

Naturalization refusals can be challenged, as a rule within one month of notification, by an objection (Widerspruch) or by an action at the administrative court, depending on the Land. A refusal does not change your residence status: the permit or settlement permit you hold stays as it is. The real decision is whether to challenge the refusal or to apply again once the missing requirement is met.

Grounds the authorities rely on

Naturalization after five years is a legal entitlement under § 10 StAG. If every requirement is met and no ground for exclusion applies, the authority has no discretion to refuse. Refusals therefore almost always turn on a specific requirement. These come up most often:

  • a livelihood that depends on benefits under the Second or Twelfth Book of the Social Code (§ 10 Abs. 1 S. 1 Nr. 3 StAG), subject to narrow exceptions, for example for someone in full-time work for at least 20 of the last 24 months

  • a residence permit that does not qualify, such as one for study, training or job-seeking (§ 10 Abs. 1 S. 1 Nr. 2 StAG)

  • no proof of German at level B1 or of a passed naturalization test (§ 10 Abs. 1 S. 1 Nr. 6 and 7, Abs. 4 and 5 StAG)

  • criminal convictions above the limits of § 12a Abs. 1 StAG, which as a rule disregards fines of up to 90 daily rates and prison sentences of up to three months that were suspended and then remitted, but not convictions for antisemitic, racist or other inhumane offenses

  • identity and nationality that the authority considers not clarified, or five years of lawful habitual residence that it counts differently from you

  • the grounds for exclusion in § 11 StAG, including indications that the declaration of commitment to the free democratic basic order was not truthful

Since 30 October 2025, the three-year fast track for special integration under the former § 10 Abs. 3 StAG no longer exists, so an application that relied on it now needs the full five years.

In Berlin, the Landesamt für Einwanderung (LEA) recorded 39,034 naturalizations and 1,931 refusals and other negative decisions in nationality matters in 2025. Its fact sheet attributes the rising number of refusals partly to applications filed before the requirements were fully met.

A ten-year bar to keep in view

One provision raises the stakes beyond a single application. Under § 35a StAG, in force since 24 December 2025, naturalization is barred for ten years where the authority finds in the procedure that the applicant deceived, threatened or bribed, or intentionally gave or used false or incomplete information about an essential requirement. That finding is immediately enforceable: an objection or action against it has no suspensive effect. A refusal that rests on a § 35a finding is a different matter from a refusal for a missing certificate, and it needs a response on the facts.

Widerspruch or Klage: rules differ by Land

Federal law requires an objection procedure before an action unless a law dispenses with it (§ 68 VwGO). The Länder have gone different ways. In Berlin, naturalization decisions are made by the LEA, and the Senate Department for the Interior decides on objections against them, under the Berlin act establishing the LEA as amended with effect from 1 January 2024. In Bavaria, the objection procedure has been abolished outside a list of fields that does not include nationality law (Art. 12 Abs. 2 AGVwGO), so a refusal goes straight to the Verwaltungsgericht.

The refusal notice states which remedy applies, where to file it and the deadline. An objection must be filed within one month of notification (§ 70 Abs. 1 VwGO). Where no objection applies, the action must be filed within one month (§ 74 Abs. 1 S. 2 and Abs. 2 VwGO). If the instructions on remedies are missing or wrong, the period is one year (§ 58 Abs. 2 VwGO), but that is a fallback to argue about later, not a deadline to plan around.

If the objection itself is left undecided, § 75 VwGO allows an action once three months have passed without a sufficient reason for the delay. The same mechanism for a pending application is explained in Untätigkeitsklage for Berlin naturalization delays.

Challenging the decision or starting again

Nothing in the StAG imposes a waiting period after an ordinary refusal; you can apply again at any time, apart from the ten-year bar under § 35a. A new application costs the fee of €255 again and starts a new procedure, with current documents and the current law.

A new application is usually the better step when the refusal was correct at the time and the gap has since closed: you have passed the B1 exam, the naturalization test or the full five years, or your income no longer depends on benefits. A challenge is the better step when the authority got the law or the facts wrong. Typical examples are residence periods counted wrongly, a residence title treated as non-qualifying when it qualifies, a conviction counted that § 12a disregards, or a livelihood assessment that ignored a full-time job. Courts apply the law in force when they make their decision, so an objection or action cannot preserve a rule that has since been repealed. The checklist in naturalization after five years is a good way to test which requirement the refusal turns on.

Withdrawing to avoid a refusal

Offices sometimes suggest withdrawing an application, often after a hearing letter (see Anhörung letter before a refusal). A withdrawal ends the procedure without a decision. There is then no refusal with reasons on file and nothing to challenge, and you can apply again later. It does not necessarily save money: a withdrawal after the authority has started to examine the application costs between €25 and €255, the same range as a refusal (§ 38 Abs. 2 S. 3 StAG). According to the Tagesspiegel, a little over 1,700 naturalization applications were withdrawn in Berlin in 2025.

Withdraw only after checking whether the office's reason holds up. If it does not, a withdrawal gives up an application that might have succeeded, and a later application is judged under whatever law applies then. Where the reason is sound and the gap will close soon, withdrawing and reapplying is often the cleaner path.

FAQ

Does a refused naturalization affect my residence permit?

No. Naturalization and residence are separate procedures. The refusal of naturalization does not change your residence permit or settlement permit, although the facts behind a refusal can matter for residence decisions in their own right.

How soon can I apply again after a refusal?

There is no statutory waiting period after an ordinary refusal. The exception is a finding under § 35a StAG of deception or intentionally false information, which bars naturalization for ten years.

Does an objection cost anything if it fails?

Yes. If the authority rejects an objection after it has started to examine it, the fee is between €25 and the full naturalization fee of €255 (§ 38 Abs. 2 S. 3 StAG). A court action has its own court fee.

When to get a lawyer

The best moment for advice is when the refusal arrives, or earlier, when a hearing letter announces one. Within the month, a lawyer can read the reasons against §§ 10 to 12b StAG, request the file to see what the office relied on, and tell you whether the refusal can be attacked or whether a new application is the faster path. Representation matters most where the refusal rests on a legal assessment, such as how residence periods were counted, whether a conviction can be disregarded or how income was assessed, and in every case that involves a finding under § 35a StAG.

Plan your next step toward German citizenship

As a German immigration and citizenship lawyer (Rechtsanwältin), Fiona Macdonald advises English-speakers on naturalization and the requirements behind it. In a Rejection & Hearing Review, she reads the refusal and your documents before the call and goes through the options, their prospects and their cost with you. If the better course is a new application, a Citizenship Strategy Session maps the path to it. Fiona Macdonald advises clients anywhere in Germany and internationally by video.

Related reading

Sources

Cover image: Flocci Nivis, CC BY 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons (cropped).

Last reviewed: November 2026 — RAin Fiona Macdonald

This article reflects information available at the review date above and may not remain current as rules and practice change. It is general information only, not legal advice, and does not create a lawyer–client relationship. Liability for reliance on its contents is excluded to the extent permitted by law.

© 2026 Fiona Macdonald Rechtsanwältin

​

Imprint

bottom of page