top of page

The Federal Employment Agency Said No: Your Options for the Work Permit

3 days ago
3 min read

The Bundesagentur für Arbeit (Federal Employment Agency, BA) does not issue visas or residence permits. For many jobs, though, the embassy or the Ausländerbehörde (immigration office) may only grant a permit for employment if the BA has approved it (§ 39 AufenthG). When the BA refuses, the refusal of the visa or permit usually follows. There are still several ways forward, and they start with understanding why the approval was refused.

An internal step, not a decision you can sue over

The BA's approval is given to the authority that issues the permit, not to you. The Federal Administrative Court treats it as an internal step between authorities, and the same applies to a pre-approval obtained by the employer in advance (BVerwG, 19 November 2019, 1 C 41.18). You therefore cannot bring a lawsuit against the BA's refusal on its own.

What you challenge is the refusal of the visa or residence permit. In those proceedings the court involves the BA as a party (Beiladung, § 65 VwGO) and examines whether its reasons hold up. A visa refusal goes to the Verwaltungsgericht Berlin within one month; for a permit refused in Germany, the notice names the remedy and the deadline.

Common reasons for a refusal

Where approval is required, the BA checks the conditions of the job. The most frequent problem is pay or working conditions that are worse than those of comparable workers in Germany, for example a salary below the local level for the role, or a contract that does not say clearly how many hours are worked. For some kinds of employment the BA also checks whether suitable applicants from Germany or the EU are available. A refusal can also follow when the employer did not answer the BA's questions.

The refusal letter or the permit refusal usually names the reason in a sentence or two. The authority's file, which you or your lawyer can inspect, often says more.

Fixing the offer and applying again

If the problem lies in the contract, a corrected offer is often the fastest path. The employer can raise the salary to the local level, set out the hours and duties precisely, or answer the BA's questions in full. A new application can then be made. Employers can also ask the BA for a pre-approval before the visa or permit application is filed; the BA should decide on it in advance where the employer has supplied the necessary information and this speeds up the procedure (§ 36 Abs. 3 BeschV).

Silence from the BA

The BA has a short time to respond. Its approval is treated as given if it does not tell the authority within two weeks that the information is insufficient or that the employer has not answered in time. In the accelerated skilled worker procedure the period is one week (§ 36 Abs. 2 BeschV). If an authority refuses a permit on the ground that approval is missing, it is worth checking the dates in the file.

When to get a lawyer

A BA refusal often comes down to a single sentence in the employment contract or a salary comparison that can be argued either way. Advice helps decide whether to correct the offer and reapply, or to challenge the permit refusal because the BA got it wrong. Where an extension in Germany was refused, the question of an urgent application to protect your stay also arises. Employment-law questions about the contract itself belong with a Fachanwalt für Arbeitsrecht.

Turn the refusal into a workable plan

Fiona Macdonald is a German immigration lawyer (Rechtsanwältin) who advises professionals and their employers on work visas, the EU Blue Card and skilled worker permits. In a Rejection & Hearing Review she reads the refusal and the contract before the call and sets out whether a corrected offer or a challenge is the better path. Fiona Macdonald advises clients anywhere in Germany and internationally by video.

Related reading

Sources

Cover image: Bundesagentur für Arbeit, Nuremberg, by Erdumlauf, CC BY 3.0, via Wikimedia Commons.

Last reviewed: November 2026 — RAin Fiona Macdonald

This article reflects information available at the review date above and may not remain current as rules and practice change. It is general information only, not legal advice, and does not create a lawyer–client relationship. Liability for reliance on its contents is excluded to the extent permitted by law.

© 2026 Fiona Macdonald Rechtsanwältin

​

Imprint

bottom of page