An Offer to Settle Your Visa Lawsuit: What It Promises and What It Costs
Many visa lawsuits at the Verwaltungsgericht Berlin never reach a judgment. Months after filing, a letter arrives from the court or from the Federal Foreign Office: the embassy is prepared to issue the visa, or to decide the application again, if the lawsuit is ended. Often this is the fastest way to the visa. Whether the offer is a good one depends on three things: what exactly is promised, how the case formally ends, and who pays.
Why the Foreign Office settles
The Federal Foreign Office conducts every visa lawsuit for the Federal Republic at the Verwaltungsgericht Berlin, the court that hears all actions against German embassies and consulates (§ 52 Nr. 2 S. 5 VwGO). Once its litigation team has the embassy's file and your arguments in front of it, a refusal can look weaker than it did at the embassy, especially when new documents have answered the original reason, such as a recognition notice that arrived after the refusal. Ending the case by agreement spares both sides a hearing and the risk of a judgment.
How the case is brought to a conclusion
Which of these an offer uses matters more than its wording suggests.
A formal court settlement. Both sides agree to end the case, either on the record before the court or by accepting in writing a settlement proposal that the court has issued by order (§ 106 VwGO). A court settlement is an enforceable title (§ 168 Abs. 1 Nr. 3 VwGO): if the embassy does not do what it promised, the promise can be enforced without a new lawsuit.
Withdrawal in return for a promise. The Foreign Office commits in writing to issue the visa or to decide again, and in return the applicant withdraws the lawsuit (§ 92 VwGO). In Berlin visa cases this is a common form. It creates no enforceable title. If the promise is not kept, the path back is a new application and, if necessary, a new lawsuit.
The embassy simply issues the visa. If the visa is issued while the case is pending, both sides declare the case settled, and the court decides on the costs at its discretion, taking into account how the case stood at that point (§ 161 Abs. 2 VwGO).
Who pays
Without an agreement on costs, the law sets the defaults. Whoever withdraws a lawsuit bears the costs (§ 155 Abs. 2 VwGO). In a formal court settlement that says nothing about costs, the court fees are split equally and each side pays its own lawyer (§ 160 VwGO). A cost clause agreed for an out-of-court withdrawal takes precedence over the withdrawal rule: the Higher Administrative Court Berlin-Brandenburg has held exactly that (OVG Berlin-Brandenburg, 8 December 2020, OVG 6 A 2/20), and the Federal Administrative Court treats such an agreement as binding on the court's cost decision (BVerwG, 24 January 2017, 3 A 1.17).
In practice, offers often ask the applicant to carry the costs of the case: the court fee and your own lawyer's fees. The court fee itself drops when a case ends without a judgment. The Verwaltungsgericht Berlin points out that usually only one court fee is then due, which at the usual value of €5,000 is €170.50 instead of €511.50.
Before you accept
Read the promise first. A commitment to issue the visa is worth much more than a commitment to decide the application again, which can end in a second refusal. Check the conditions attached to it, such as a valid passport, the job offer still standing or the usual security checks, and whether there is a time frame. A contract with a fixed start date can make a delay costly even if the visa comes in the end. Then look at the form: where a lot depends on the promise, a formal court settlement gives you something you can enforce, and a letter followed by a withdrawal does not.
Turning the offer down is also possible. The case then continues, usually to a hearing and a judgment, which takes longer and can go either way.
When to get a lawyer
An offer usually comes with a short deadline, and accepting it ends the case. A lawyer who has read the embassy's file can judge whether the lawsuit would probably succeed, whether the wording secures the visa or only a new decision, and whether the cost clause is fair given the strength of the case. If the case goes on to the Oberverwaltungsgericht, representation by a lawyer is mandatory (§ 67 Abs. 4 VwGO).
Weigh the offer with someone who knows the file
Fiona Macdonald is a German immigration lawyer (Rechtsanwältin) who represents visa applicants at the Verwaltungsgericht Berlin, including in settlement talks with the Federal Foreign Office. In a consultation she goes through the offer with you and explains what it secures and what it costs. Fiona Macdonald advises clients anywhere in Germany and internationally by video.
Related reading
Sources
§ 52, § 67, § 92, § 106, § 155, § 160, § 161 and § 168 VwGO, dejure.org, https://dejure.org/gesetze/VwGO (accessed 17 November 2026).
OVG Berlin-Brandenburg, decision of 8 December 2020, OVG 6 A 2/20, https://gerichtsentscheidungen.brandenburg.de/gerichtsentscheidung/1726 (accessed 17 November 2026).
Bundesverwaltungsgericht, decision of 24 January 2017, 3 A 1.17, https://www.bverwg.de/240117B3A1.17.0 (accessed 17 November 2026).
Verwaltungsgericht Berlin, "Kosten und Prozesskostenhilfe", https://www.berlin.de/gerichte/verwaltungsgericht/service/kosten-und-prozesskostenhilfe/ (accessed 17 November 2026).
Cover image: Auswärtiges Amt, Berlin, by Andreas Praefcke, CC BY 3.0, via Wikimedia Commons.
Last reviewed: November 2026 — RAin Fiona Macdonald
This article reflects information available at the review date above and may not remain current as rules and practice change. It is general information only, not legal advice, and does not create a lawyer–client relationship. Liability for reliance on its contents is excluded to the extent permitted by law.


