Applied Under the 3-Year Fast Track? What the Repeal Means for Your Application
Since 30 October 2025, German law no longer allows naturalization after three years for special integration achievements. The repeal of § 10 Abs. 3 StAG came without a transitional rule, and courts apply the law in force when they decide, so an application filed under the old rule can no longer be granted on that basis. What remains is the five-year path under § 10 Abs. 1 StAG, discretionary naturalization under § 8 StAG in narrow cases, and practical choices about the pending file.
The repeal and the missing transitional rule
Article 1 of the Gesetz zur Änderung des Staatsangehörigkeitsgesetzes sowie weiterer Vorschriften of 27 October 2025 struck out § 10 Abs. 3 StAG. The act was published on 29 October 2025 (BGBl. 2025 I Nr. 256) and that article entered into force the next day. § 10 Abs. 3 now simply reads "(aufgehoben)" (repealed).
During the legislative process, the Bundesrat's committees proposed a transitional rule for applications filed before 28 May 2025. It was not adopted, and the Bundesrat did not call the mediation committee. The Administrative Court of Trier read this as a deliberate choice not to protect pending applications.
The old provision allowed naturalization after three years for applicants who showed special integration achievements and German at C1 level. The five-year path needs B1 (§ 10 Abs. 4 StAG), so language will not be what stands in your way.
Courts look at the law on the day they decide
In a naturalization case, the decisive moment is the office's decision or, once the case is in court, the last oral hearing. A change in the law during the procedure applies, even to the applicant's disadvantage, unless the law itself says that earlier applications are to be decided under the old rules (BVerwG, judgment of 20 October 2005, 5 C 8.05). With no such rule here, the Administrative Court of Trier dismissed the action of an applicant who had applied in April 2025 and sued for failure to act in July 2025 (VG Trier, judgment of 3 December 2025, 8 K 5461/25.TR).
The Trier court also rejected the argument from legitimate expectations. It treated the repeal as a permissible unechte Rückwirkung (a new rule applied to a procedure not yet concluded) and found that, at least once the coalition agreement of April 2025 announced the end of the fast track, applicants could no longer rely on it. It noted that the applicant had made no irreversible decision in reliance on the old law, such as giving up his previous citizenship. The judgment was open to an application for leave to appeal.
In Berlin, the Senate reported in June 2026 that the Administrative Court of Berlin had upheld the Landesamt für Einwanderung's practice of refusing these applications, even those filed before the repeal, in an interim-relief decision of 26 May 2026 (VG 39 L 209/26). At that time, nine proceedings concerning the old § 10 Abs. 3 were pending at the Higher Administrative Court of Berlin-Brandenburg.
The Federal Constitutional Court declined to hear a constitutional complaint from an applicant whose naturalization certificate was ready to be handed over on 31 October 2025, one day after the repeal (BVerfG, order of 19 December 2025, 2 BvR 1792/25). It did not rule on the substance. The complainant had not first gone through the administrative courts, and had not explained why § 8 StAG could not protect the complainant’s reliance on the old law.
Keeping the application open until five years
For many applicants the simplest answer is time. Because the relevant moment is when the decision is made, an application that is still pending once you have five years of lawful habitual residence can be granted under § 10 Abs. 1 StAG, as long as the other requirements are met at that point. The same rule that ended the fast-track works in your favor here.
The Landesamt für Einwanderung in Berlin handles it this way. With the applicant's consent, or if the applicant does not object, it suspends the application for up to two years and puts it back on the desk when five years are expected to be complete, then examines it on updated documents. If the five years are already complete when the file is reached, it checks the remaining requirements and, if they are met, invites the applicant to the naturalization. Other offices are not bound by this practice, so ask your office in writing how it will proceed.
Check your count before relying on it. The five years must be lawful residence, and absences abroad of more than six months can break habitual residence (§ 12b StAG). The post on gaps in residence explains the rules.
Withdrawal versus a refusal
If five years are still some way off, or the office will not keep the file open, the choice is between insisting on a decision and withdrawing. Insisting means a refusal, as the Berlin office states openly. A refusal based only on the residence period does not bar a later application, and you can apply again once you qualify.
The fee is similar either way. Under § 38 Abs. 2 S. 3 StAG, a refusal, or a withdrawal after the office has begun to process the application on the merits, costs between €25 and the full naturalization fee of €255. A withdrawal ends the matter without a decision on your file. A refusal keeps open the option of challenging it, which matters only if you have a real argument under § 8 StAG.
Discretion under § 8 StAG
§ 8 StAG allows naturalization at the office's discretion without a fixed minimum residence period, if identity and nationality are clarified and the applicant has no relevant conviction, has somewhere to live and can support the family. The Federal Constitutional Court pointed to this provision in December 2025: in exercising its discretion under § 8, the office is required to take reliance on the old law into account.
Courts set the bar high. According to VG Trier, the discretion narrows to a duty to naturalize only where the office itself frustrated an existing claim through unlawful inaction, a Folgenbeseitigungslast (a duty to undo the consequences of its own unlawful conduct). That requires a file that was ready for decision, formally and on the merits, including the security checks under § 37 StAG, and an office that exceeded a reasonable time to decide. The same court regarded up to about a year as generally reasonable for a naturalization, and in that case the intelligence services had not yet replied.
The argument is therefore strongest where the office had completed its checks before 30 October 2025, for example where it had already sent an invitation to collect the certificate, and the delay lay with the office. It does not help where the file was incomplete or still waiting for the security check.
Where an Untätigkeitsklage fits now
An Untätigkeitsklage (action for failure to act) under § 75 VwGO could never make the old law continue to apply. The court decides on the law in force at the time of its own decision, so an action filed in 2025 left the applicant in the same position once the repeal took effect, as the Trier case shows. It could only have made a difference by bringing about a positive decision on a complete file before 30 October 2025. Since an action generally cannot be filed until three months after the application (§ 75 S. 2 VwGO), and courts allow an office with a sufficient reason more time, there was little room for that with applications filed in 2025.
A pending action can still serve you in two ways. If you reach five years before the court decides, the court applies § 10 Abs. 1 StAG to the facts as they are then and can order the office to naturalize you if everything else is in place. And the record of the delay, from the date your file was complete to the date it would have been decided, is the factual basis for any argument under § 8. When an action makes sense is set out in When can you file an Untätigkeitsklage? and, for Berlin, in the post on naturalization delays at the LEA.
Pending fast-track files: common questions
I applied under the three-year rule before 30 October 2025. Is my application still pending?
Yes, unless you withdrew it or it was refused. It is an application for naturalization, and the office decides it under the current law. It cannot be granted under the repealed § 10 Abs. 3, but it can be granted under § 10 Abs. 1 once you have five years and meet the other requirements.
Does it help that the office took so long?
Not for the three-year rule. The decision date governs, and the courts have so far rejected arguments based on the filing date. A long delay on a file that was ready for decision can support a discretionary argument under § 8 StAG.
Do I need a new language certificate?
No higher level is needed: the five-year path requires B1, and the fast track required C1. Other documents, such as payslips, will usually have to be brought up to date before a decision.
When to get a lawyer
Get advice if your office has announced a refusal or asked whether you agree to a suspension, if you have received a refusal and the deadline to challenge it is running, or if your file was complete and checked before 30 October 2025. In that last case, the facts of the delay decide whether a § 8 argument is worth making, and they are best taken from the file early, through an inspection of the records.
Decide the next step for a fast-track file
Fiona Macdonald advises applicants whose naturalization was filed under the former three-year rule on whether to wait, withdraw or contest a refusal, and on the five-year application that follows. Fiona Macdonald advises clients anywhere in Germany and internationally by video.
Related reading
Sources
§ 10 StAG (text in the version of Art. 1 of the act of 27 October 2025, BGBl. 2025 I Nr. 256, in force 30 October 2025), buzer.de, https://www.buzer.de/s1.htm?a=10&g=StAG (accessed 23 October 2026).
§ 8 StAG, buzer.de, https://www.buzer.de/s1.htm?a=8&g=StAG (accessed 23 October 2026).
§ 12b StAG, buzer.de, https://www.buzer.de/s1.htm?a=12b&g=StAG (accessed 23 October 2026).
§ 38 StAG, buzer.de, https://www.buzer.de/s1.htm?a=38&g=StAG (accessed 23 October 2026).
§ 75 VwGO, buzer.de, https://www.buzer.de/s1.htm?a=75&g=VwGO (accessed 23 October 2026).
VG Trier, judgment of 3 December 2025, 8 K 5461/25.TR, justiz.rlp.de, https://justiz.rlp.de/fileadmin/justiz/Gerichte/Fachgerichte/Verwaltungsgerichte/Trier/Entscheidungen/8_K_5461-25_TR_Urteil_vom_03_12_2025.pdf (accessed 23 October 2026).
BVerfG, order of the 3rd Chamber of the Second Senate of 19 December 2025, 2 BvR 1792/25, bundesverfassungsgericht.de, https://www.bverfg.de/e/rk20251219_2bvr179225 (accessed 23 October 2026).
Abgeordnetenhaus Berlin, Drucksache 19/26325, Umgang des LEA mit Einbürgerungsanträgen nach dem vormaligen § 10 Abs. 3 StAG (answer of 24 June 2026), pardok.parlament-berlin.de, https://pardok.parlament-berlin.de/starweb/adis/citat/VT/19/SchrAnfr/S19-26325.pdf (accessed 23 October 2026).
Deutscher Bundestag, Drucksache 21/537, Gesetzentwurf der Bundesregierung (23 June 2025), dserver.bundestag.de, https://dserver.bundestag.de/btd/21/005/2100537.pdf (accessed 23 October 2026).
Last reviewed: November 2026 — RAin Fiona Macdonald
This article reflects information available at the review date above and may not remain current as rules and practice change. It is general information only, not legal advice, and does not create a lawyer–client relationship. Liability for reliance on its contents is excluded to the extent permitted by law.


