Citizenship Application Pending at the BVA for Years? Article 116, § 15 Applications and § 5 Declarations
On 19 October 2026, the Federal Office of Administration (Bundesverwaltungsamt, BVA) announced temporary delays in naturalizations under Article 116 Abs. 2 GG while it reviews its checks, following reports of forgery and fraud. Applications under § 15 StAG are expressly not affected, and the notice does not mention declarations under § 5 StAG. For all three, an Untätigkeitsklage (action for failure to act) under § 75 VwGO is available in principle once three months have passed without a decision, although for Article 116 files the BVA can be expected to cite the review as a reason for the wait.
This post is about delay, not eligibility. It assumes the application or declaration went in with the documents the BVA asked for and that the file has since gone quiet: a confirmation of receipt, perhaps one request for a further certificate, and then nothing for a year or more.
The BVA's notice of 19 October 2026
The notice, published in German and English on the BVA's citizenship pages, says the BVA is reviewing "the procedural and review processes for naturalization for the purpose of redress under Article 116 of the Basic Law", in close coordination with the investigative authorities. The reason it gives is reports of criminal forgery and fraud, and the aim is to safeguard the procedure against such activity. As a result, it expects temporary delays both in reviewing applications and in the handing over of certificates by German embassies and consulates abroad. Its last sentence matters for many readers: proceedings under § 15 StAG are not affected.
The notice gives no end date and no figures, and it does not suggest that individual applicants are under suspicion. A parliamentary question published earlier in October (Bundestag document 21/8465) cites a press report that the Düsseldorf public prosecutor's office and the Federal Criminal Police Office are investigating 32 suspects over Article 116 naturalizations obtained or sought with manipulated documents. For an applicant with genuine documents, the practical effect is a further wait on top of processing times that were already long.
Three procedures, three kinds of delay
Article 116 Abs. 2 GG gives former German citizens who were deprived of their citizenship between 30 January 1933 and 8 May 1945 on political, racial or religious grounds, and their descendants, a right to be naturalized on application. The naturalization takes effect only when the certificate is handed over (§ 16 S. 1 StAG). A delay at the handover stage is therefore more than a formality: until the certificate is in your hands, you have not yet become German on this basis.
§ 15 StAG, available since 20 August 2021, covers people who lost or could not acquire German citizenship in other ways connected with Nazi persecution, and their descendants. It is also a naturalization on application, also effective on handover, and according to the BVA outside the current review. A stalled § 15 file cannot be explained by the October notice.
§ 5 StAG works differently. It is a declaration (Erklärung), not an application for naturalization, open to people born after the Basic Law came into force who did not acquire German citizenship at birth because of discriminatory rules, for example the child of a German mother and a foreign father born before 1975, and to their descendants. The declaration can be made until 19 August 2031 (§ 5 Abs. 3 StAG), and the BVA issues a certificate of acquisition (§ 5 Abs. 4 StAG). The BVA's own guidance says declarations are dealt with in order of receipt and that involving the domestic intelligence service is required by law. The October notice says nothing about § 5.
Cologne as the competent court
The BVA is a federal authority based in Cologne. An action to compel a federal authority to issue an administrative act goes to the administrative court in whose district the authority has its seat (§ 52 Nr. 2 S. 1 and 2 VwGO), so a BVA case belongs at the Administrative Court of Cologne (Verwaltungsgericht Köln), wherever in the world the applicant lives. Appeals from Cologne go to the Higher Administrative Court of North Rhine-Westphalia (OVG NRW).
Proceedings at the court are in German, as is the BVA procedure itself. There is no requirement to be represented by a lawyer at the administrative court, but the court can require a party who lives abroad to appoint an agent for service in Germany (§ 56 Abs. 3 VwGO).
Is the fraud review a sufficient reason?
Under § 75 VwGO, the action can be filed three months after the application. The court then asks whether the BVA has a zureichender Grund (sufficient reason) for not having decided. If it has, the court suspends the case and sets a deadline for the decision, which it can extend (§ 75 S. 3 VwGO).
The OVG NRW, which hears appeals from Cologne, held in September 2025 that an authority's lasting overload is not a sufficient reason, because staffing is a problem the authority's leadership has to solve. A temporary surge in applications, for example after a change in the law, can be. The BVA has for years pointed to the rise in applications since 2021 and to dealing with files strictly in order of receipt. The review announced on 19 October 2026 gives it a further argument.
A review of anti-fraud checks, carried out with investigators, is the kind of reason the BVA will present as specific and temporary rather than structural. There are counterarguments. The notice describes a review of procedures, not a concern about any particular file. It names no end date, and "temporary" becomes harder to maintain the longer it lasts. It cannot explain a delay in a § 15 file, which the BVA itself says is unaffected, or in a § 5 declaration, which the notice does not mention. And a file that was already overdue before 19 October 2026 was overdue for reasons the notice does not address.
For an Article 116 file, a realistic expectation is that the court may suspend the case for a period and require the BVA to decide within it. Even then, a deadline set by a court is more than an applicant had before filing.
Paper trail for a BVA file
What helps in court is whatever shows the chronology. Keep the dated proof of submission, whether by post, through a German embassy or consulate or online through the federal administration portal; the BVA's confirmation of receipt and file reference; every request for documents and the date you answered it; and your status inquiries with any replies. If the application went through an embassy or consulate, note the date you handed it in and, if you know it, the date it reached Cologne.
A short, written status inquiry before filing is worthwhile. It gives the BVA a chance to name anything that is missing, and its reply, or the lack of one, shows the court what the BVA knew and when.
Frequently asked questions
Does the October 2026 notice affect my § 15 StAG application?
No. The BVA states that proceedings under § 15 StAG are not affected by the review. A delay in a § 15 file must be justified on its own terms.
Can I sue the BVA while living outside Germany?
Yes. The action goes to the Administrative Court of Cologne regardless of where you live. Proceedings are in German, and the court can ask you to appoint an agent for service in Germany.
My Article 116 application has been approved. Am I already a German citizen?
Not yet. Naturalization takes effect when the certificate is handed over (§ 16 S. 1 StAG), and the BVA has said that the handover through embassies and consulates abroad will also take longer for a time.
Will an action count against my application?
The action concerns timing. It does not change the requirements the BVA applies to your file, and the BVA still has to decide on the merits.
When to get a lawyer
Advice makes sense once three months have passed since a complete application or declaration and a status inquiry has produced nothing concrete, and earlier where the delay has real consequences, such as a planned move to Germany or a job that depends on an EU passport. A lawyer can assess whether the BVA can point to a sufficient reason in your particular file, now that the Article 116 review gives it a new argument, and file in Cologne in a way that puts the costs on the Federal Republic if the BVA decides only after the action.
Advice on a delayed BVA file
Fiona Macdonald advises applicants whose Article 116, § 15 or § 5 file has stalled at the BVA and files actions for failure to act at a flat fee of €1,500 plus the court fee advance. The action can also be requested directly through the Untätigkeitsklage request form. Fiona Macdonald advises clients anywhere in Germany and internationally by video.
Related reading
Sources
Bundesverwaltungsamt, "Naturalization under Article 116 of the Basic Law: Temporary procedural delays" / "Einbürgerung gemäß Artikel 116 des Grundgesetzes: Vorübergehende Verfahrensverzögerungen", notice of 19 October 2026, https://www.bva.bund.de/DE/Services/Buerger/Ausweis-Dokumente-Recht/Staatsangehoerigkeit/_documents/Meldung/20261019_citizenship.html (accessed 23 October 2026).
Bundesverwaltungsamt, "Wie lange dauert das Verfahren zum Erklärungserwerb?", https://www.bva.bund.de/DE/Services/Buerger/Ausweis-Dokumente-Recht/Staatsangehoerigkeit/Einbuergerung/EER/Infobox_EER/Infobox_EER_4.html (accessed 23 October 2026).
Bundesverwaltungsamt, "Zuständigkeiten in Staatsangehörigkeitsverfahren", https://www.bva.bund.de/DE/Services/Buerger/Ausweis-Dokumente-Recht/Staatsangehoerigkeit/Service/Zustaendigkeit/Zustaendigkeit_node.html (accessed 23 October 2026).
Deutscher Bundestag, hib 811/2026 of 12 October 2026, "Einbürgerungen nach Grundgesetz-Artikel 116 Absatz 2" (Kleine Anfrage, Drucksache 21/8465), https://www.bundestag.de/presse/hib/kurzmeldungen-1224350 (accessed 23 October 2026).
Art. 116 GG, https://www.gesetze-im-internet.de/gg/art_116.html
§ 5, § 15 and § 16 StAG, https://www.gesetze-im-internet.de/stag/
§ 52, § 56, § 75 and § 161 VwGO, https://www.gesetze-im-internet.de/vwgo/
OVG NRW, decision of 17 September 2025, 19 E 310/25, https://nrwe.justiz.nrw.de/ovgs/ovg_nrw/j2025/19_E_310_25_Beschluss_20250917.html
Cover image: HOWI, CC BY 3.0, via Wikimedia Commons (cropped).
Last reviewed: October 2026 — RAin Fiona Macdonald
This article reflects information available at the review date above and may not remain current as rules and practice change. It is general information only, not legal advice, and does not create a lawyer–client relationship. Liability for reliance on its contents is excluded to the extent permitted by law.


